FCA Consumer Duty Board Report: What Boards Must Evidence Now (2026–27)
Last updated: 19 October 2026 — revised for the FCA’s Year 2 observations (April 2026) and its CP26/23 proposals on board reporting.
Under the FCA’s Consumer Duty (PS22/9), which has applied to open retail products and services since 31 July 2023 and to closed products since 31 July 2024, a firm’s board must review and approve an assessment of whether the firm is delivering good outcomes for retail customers at least once a year. That assessment has to cover the three cross-cutting rules — acting in good faith, avoiding foreseeable harm, and enabling customers to pursue their financial objectives — and the four outcomes: products and services, price and value, consumer understanding, and consumer support. Most firms have kept the July cycle set by the first deadline, so the third annual report has now been through the board. The question for 2027 is whether the next one shows the FCA what it asked for after Year 2.
What Does the FCA Now Expect From a Consumer Duty Board Report?
The FCA’s expectations have moved on from the first reporting year. Reports that describe governance structures and monitoring frameworks in abstract terms are no longer enough. The regulator wants measurable consumer outcomes with trend data, root cause analysis, and evidence that board challenge has led to real improvements.
In practice that means: outcome monitoring data for all four outcomes; trend analysis against previous years; identification of poor outcomes and the specific corrective action taken; evidence that the firm understands how outcomes are delivered through intermediaries and other third parties; and explicit documentation of the board’s challenge — questions asked, issues raised and follow-up actions recorded in board minutes.
In its April 2026 review of Year 2 board reports, the FCA found that most boards formally reviewed and approved their reports, but many did not document the challenge they provided. It asked boards to make sure minutes and papers set out the discussions held, the questions asked and the follow-up actions requested. A report without that evidence is a weak basis for showing the board is overseeing outcomes, and invites supervisory questions.
Executive Action
- Review your most recent board report against the FCA’s April 2026 observations and list the gaps before the next cycle begins.
- Ensure board minutes for Consumer Duty items record the specific questions asked by directors and management’s responses — not just “the board approved the report”.
- Build an evidence pack with quantitative outcome metrics and year-on-year trend data for each of the four outcomes.
Where Did Year 2 Reports Fall Short — and What Must Boards Fix?
The FCA saw real progress in Year 2: boards formally approving reports and confirming sign-off of actions, fuller action plans with named owners and timelines, and broader use of data including trend and root cause analysis. But it also set out clear areas for improvement.
Data without conclusions. Some firms presented large volumes of management information without explaining what it showed about customer outcomes. The FCA wants firms to go beyond MI dashboards — to draw conclusions, identify emerging risks and challenge their own practices.
Weak distribution chain monitoring. Monitoring of outcomes in distribution chains was often weak, particularly where firms rely on intermediaries or outsourcing partners. Boards need to show they understand how products and services are sold and supported downstream, not just inside the firm. The FCA said it would consult on rules and guidance for distribution chains.
Undocumented board challenge. Approving a management report is not the same as challenging it. Boards should probe data quality, methodology and corrective action plans — and record those questions formally.
Thin evidence on understanding and support. Some reports concentrated on products, services and value, with less on consumer understanding and support. The FCA expects firms to show how they test communications, assess comprehension and respond to signs of misunderstanding or friction — including outcomes for customers with characteristics of vulnerability.
Executive Action
- Commission a distribution chain review — map every third party through which your products reach retail customers and what outcome data you receive from each.
- Hold a board session dedicated to Consumer Duty, run as a challenge meeting rather than an approval meeting, with questions circulated to directors in advance.
- Ask for a specific section on customers with characteristics of vulnerability: how they are identified, supported and how their outcomes compare.
How Should Boards Structure the Evidence Pack?
The strongest board reports are built around evidence, not process. Rather than describing what the firm does, they show what outcomes have been achieved and where they have fallen short. The FCA wants to see a firm with honest insight into its own performance; a report that identifies no poor outcomes at all is unlikely to be credible.
A practical structure has seven sections: an executive summary of outcome performance against the previous year; products and services (target market, product reviews, remediation); price and value (fair value assessments and findings); consumer understanding (communications testing, comprehension evidence, complaint root causes); consumer support (service levels, resolution rates, escalation trends); customers with characteristics of vulnerability; and distribution chain monitoring. Alongside it, keep a root cause register listing each outcome weakness, its likely cause, the remediation, the accountable owner and the timeline — and have the board approve it, not just note it.
The board’s role is to test this evidence, not accept management’s characterisation at face value. Directors without a financial services background should be briefed in advance on the outcomes framework and the FCA’s observations. The INFORMD self-assessment tools can help structure that preparation.
Executive Action
- Structure the report around the seven evidence sections above, with a named data owner for each.
- Brief all directors on the FCA’s Year 2 observations before the Consumer Duty board session.
- Circulate the report well before the meeting — at least ten working days gives directors time to prepare real challenge.
What Is Changing Next: CP26/23
On 29 June 2026 the FCA published CP26/23, a consultation on the scope and proportionality of the Duty. Among its proposals: firms would no longer need a standalone Consumer Duty board report where the information is already covered in other board reporting, though the FCA would still expect Duty reporting to the board at least annually; the extent of reporting would be proportionate to a firm’s role in the distribution chain; and the Duty would be limited to customers usually resident in the UK, with exceptions such as UK funeral plans and pensions. The consultation closed on 18 September 2026 and the FCA expects to publish final rules in a policy statement in the first quarter of 2027.
These are proposals, not rules. Until the policy statement lands, boards should plan the next report on the current basis — and treat any future flexibility as a chance to integrate Duty evidence into mainstream board reporting, not to reduce it.
What Are the Consequences of an Inadequate Report?
The FCA has moved from a bedding-in stance to active supervision. Where firms cannot evidence good outcomes, the tools available range from supervisory engagement through to skilled person reviews under section 166 of FSMA and, in serious cases, enforcement action.
Accountability matters too. Under the Senior Managers and Certification Regime, responsibility for the firm’s compliance with the Duty sits with the relevant Senior Managers, and the board as a whole owns the annual assessment. A director designated as the board’s Consumer Duty lead should be fully briefed — but formal approval of a report that was never genuinely challenged is not a defence if harm later emerges.
There is also a commercial upside. Firms that engage properly with Duty data find actionable insight — poor-value products, communications customers do not understand, support journeys that generate avoidable complaints. The board report can be a management tool, not just a compliance exercise. Contact INFORMD if your governance team wants help structuring its Consumer Duty board pack.
Executive Action
- Confirm which Senior Manager holds Consumer Duty responsibility and which director leads board oversight, and that both are briefed on the FCA’s latest observations.
- Track CP26/23 and the expected Q1 2027 policy statement, and agree how the next report will respond.
- Record the board’s Consumer Duty challenge session fully in the minutes — it is your primary evidence of oversight.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a Consumer Duty board report?
It is the board’s annual assessment of whether the firm is delivering good outcomes for retail customers under the Consumer Duty. It sets out outcome monitoring across the four outcomes, any poor outcomes found and the action taken, and records the board’s review and approval.
When is the Consumer Duty board report due?
The board must review and approve the assessment at least annually. The first reports were due by 31 July 2024, and most firms have kept a July cycle since. Check your firm’s own governance calendar — and watch CP26/23, which proposes allowing the content to sit within other board reporting.
What did the FCA say about Year 2 reports?
In April 2026 the FCA reported stronger governance, better action plans and broader data use, but asked firms to link data more clearly to outcomes, strengthen distribution chain monitoring, document board challenge, and give more evidence on consumer understanding and support.
Sources: FCA — Year 2 Consumer Duty board reports; FCA — Consumer Duty board reports: good practice and areas for improvement; FCA CP26/23 (June 2026).
