How UK COOs Should Test a Transformation Programme in 2026
A UK COO can test a transformation programme with four questions on benefits, delivery evidence, change capacity and stop triggers.
This briefing draws on the approach used by the Infrastructure and Projects Authority (IPA) in its assurance reviews and on the Financial Reporting Council’s expectation, under the UK Corporate Governance Code, that boards monitor risk and internal controls. It extends our guide to briefing the board on technology strategy and our piece on how CIOs can prove AI value to the board.
Why do so many transformation programmes drift off course?
Programmes rarely fail in a single moment. They drift: scope grows, benefits are restated, and status reports stay green until a funding review. According to BCG’s 2022 survey of 860 senior executives, only about a third of digital transformations meet or exceed their target value and sustain the change.
Public-sector data shows the same pattern. According to the National Audit Office’s January 2016 briefing for the Committee of Public Accounts, 37 of 106 monitored major government projects were rated red or amber-red. The age of that figure matters less than the pattern it describes: optimistic reporting hides risk until it is expensive to fix.
Executive Action
- Ask for the last three re-baselines of the plan and what changed each time.
- Compare reported status with a sample of user, supplier and delivery-team feedback.
- Agree one set of status definitions so green means evidence, not confidence.
Question one: who owns each benefit, and where does it land in the budget?
A benefit with no owner is not a benefit. Each one needs a named business executive, a baseline, a target, a date and a budget line it will change. Your CFO should validate the arithmetic, because finance is where an overstated saving is found out.
Separate delivery benefits (the system is live) from business benefits (cost is out, revenue is in). Programmes that report the first as the second are the ones that surprise the board at year-end.
Executive Action
- Build a benefits register with owner, baseline, target, date and budget line.
- Have finance sign off each benefit and review the register quarterly.
- Stop counting a benefit until it appears in management accounts.
Question two: what delivery evidence supports the current plan?
Test the plan against working outputs, not milestones passed. Ask what has been demonstrated to users, what has been tested in production-like conditions, and what remains unbuilt. Velocity, defect trends and dependency slippage tell you more than a percentage-complete figure.
Commission an independent review at each stage gate. The IPA’s assurance reviews and the Government Functional Standard for project delivery offer a useful template: reviewers external to the programme, a clear delivery-confidence rating and a written response from the senior responsible owner.
Executive Action
- Require a live demonstration of working capability at every steering committee.
- Track dependency slippage and defect trends monthly, not just milestones.
- Commission an independent stage-gate review before the next tranche of spend.
Question three: can the organisation absorb the change?
Change capacity is the most under-measured constraint. If three programmes land on the same operations team in one quarter, the plan is not credible, whatever the Gantt chart says. Your CHRO and business-unit heads should confirm capacity, training time and the effect on business-as-usual performance.
Executive Action
- Map all concurrent change by affected team and quarter, and sequence accordingly.
- Ask each affected leader to confirm in writing that they can release the people needed.
- Measure adoption, such as usage and process compliance, not just go-live.
Question four: what would make you stop or re-scope?
Agree stop and re-scope triggers before funding is released, not after trouble starts. Triggers might include benefits forecast falling below an agreed threshold, a cost overrun beyond tolerance, or loss of the accountable executive. Pre-agreed triggers turn a painful debate into a routine decision.
For board-level reporting, align the triggers with the principal risks your audit and risk committees already track. A programme that could breach risk appetite belongs on the risk register, with the same scrutiny as any other material exposure. Our templates and assessment tools include a project review checklist you can adapt.
Executive Action
- Set quantified stop, pause and re-scope triggers in the funding approval.
- Name the person with authority to invoke them, and the committee that ratifies it.
- Link programme risk to the principal risks report to the audit and risk committees.
Frequently asked questions
At least twice a year, and at every stage gate. Reviewers should sit outside the programme and report to the COO, CEO or audit committee. Independent assurance is most useful before major spend is released, not after problems surface.
A benefits realisation plan names each expected benefit, the budget line it changes, the executive who owns it, the baseline, the target and the date. Finance should validate it. Without an owner and a baseline, a benefit is only an aspiration.
The accountable executive, usually the COO or CEO, should chair, with the CFO, CIO and business-unit leaders as members. The programme director should report to the committee, not chair it, so challenge remains independent.
Common signs are repeatedly re-baselined plans, benefits that quietly shrink, key roles changing hands, green status reports with red user feedback, and spend running ahead of delivered capability. Any two together justify an independent review.
About INFORMD
INFORMD provides intelligence briefings, tools and frameworks for senior business leaders across technology, finance, strategy and compliance. Based in Milton Keynes, UK, we help executives stay informed and act with confidence. Explore our full briefing library (/resources/) or access our free assessment tools (/tools-assessments/). To discuss a briefing for your leadership team, contact us.
Stay ahead. Subscribe to INFORMD’s weekly executive briefing at informd.co.uk (/resources/).
