Should You Pay a Ransom? A UK CEO’s Decision Protocol for 2026 | INFORMD Executive Briefing

Should You Pay a Ransom? A UK CEO’s Decision Protocol for 2026

A UK company should decide its ransom position before an attack, not during one: payment is not currently banned for private firms, but sanctions law, regulators and a proposed UK payment ban now constrain the choice.

The relevant framework is the UK government’s ransomware proposals, developed after its January 2025 consultation and supported by the National Cyber Security Centre (NCSC), the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) and sector regulators including the FCA and PRA. For a CEO, the question is no longer “would we pay?” but “who decides, on what evidence, and within what law?”

Is paying a ransom legal for a UK business today?

For most private-sector firms, payment is not itself a criminal offence. But it can become one if funds reach a sanctioned actor, or if the payment breaches terrorist financing or money laundering rules under the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002. Insurers, banks and regulators will also examine the decision afterwards.

The direction of travel is clear. According to the UK government’s consultation response, summarised by Goodwin in February 2026, 72% of respondents backed a targeted ban on ransomware payments by public sector bodies and operators of regulated critical national infrastructure. The government proposes a payment prevention regime for everyone else, requiring victims to engage the authorities before paying. Legislation is expected to travel alongside the Cyber Security and Resilience Bill, which we examined in our CISO briefing on the 24-hour reporting test.

Executive Action

  • Ask general counsel for a written view on sanctions and terrorism-finance exposure before any incident occurs.
  • Confirm whether your organisation could fall within the proposed ban as a regulated CNI operator or supplier.
  • Record the board’s ransom policy in the crisis plan, with a named legal sign-off step.

Who should own the ransom decision?

The decision belongs with the board or a delegated crisis committee, not the IT function. Payment decisions carry legal, financial, reputational and regulatory consequences that sit beyond the CISO’s remit, and directors’ duties under section 172 of the Companies Act 2006 apply in a crisis as in normal trading.

According to the UK Cyber Security Breaches Survey 2025/26, only 25% of businesses have a formal incident response plan, and board-level responsibility for cyber stands at 31%. Both gaps matter here: a firm without a plan has no decision rights, and a firm without board ownership has nobody to exercise them.

Executive Action

  • Name the decision-makers: CEO, CFO, CISO, general counsel and chair, with deputies.
  • Pre-agree a delegated authority and a quorum so the decision cannot stall at 2am.
  • Run a tabletop exercise at least annually that forces a pay-or-refuse choice.

What must be reported, and to whom, within what time?

Notification obligations run in parallel and start quickly. If personal data is at risk, UK GDPR requires notification to the ICO within 72 hours of becoming aware. FCA and PRA-regulated firms have separate notification expectations, and the DORA-style operational resilience regimes increasingly set short clocks for material incidents. Insurers typically require immediate notice and may restrict who you can appoint.

Reporting is also where reform bites. The consultation response, as summarised by Goodwin, records that 63% backed an economy-wide mandatory reporting regime, with a 72-hour initial reporting window still under consideration. Yet the Breaches Survey 2025/26 found only 40% of affected businesses reported their most disruptive breach externally. Expect that gap to close by law.

Executive Action

  • Build a single notification matrix: ICO, FCA, PRA, NCSC, Action Fraud, insurer, key customers.
  • Pre-appoint external incident responders and legal counsel approved by your insurer.
  • Test that your 72-hour evidence trail can be assembled from offline records.

How does ransomware resilience reduce the need to pay?

Recoverability is the strongest negotiating position. The Breaches Survey 2025/26 reports that 74% of businesses use cloud backups, and ransomware affected 1% of respondents, down from 3% in each of the two previous years. Low incidence is not low impact, though: ransomware is concentrated in larger organisations, where payment pressure is highest because downtime costs accumulate by the hour.

A backup that has never been restored is an assumption, not a control. Test restoration time against the maximum tolerable outage your board has actually approved, and align the result with the NCSC’s ransomware guidance and ISO 27001 controls on backup and continuity. Supplier exposure matters too: the same survey found only 6% of businesses assess their wider supply chain.

Executive Action

  • Require evidence of a full, timed restoration test from an immutable or offline backup this quarter.
  • Set a maximum tolerable outage and report restoration performance against it to the board.
  • Extend ransomware scenarios to critical suppliers and review their recovery commitments.

What should the board ask this quarter?

Four questions separate prepared firms from exposed ones. Who decides? What does our lawyer say about sanctions? Can we recover without paying? Who do we tell, and when? Our executive self-assessments and technology strategy review template can structure the discussion, and the briefing library covers related resilience topics. For tailored support, get in touch.

Video walkthroughs are coming soon in our video briefings.

Frequently asked questions

Is it illegal for a UK company to pay a ransom?

Not generally. Paying is not currently banned for private businesses, but sanctions law, terrorism legislation and money laundering rules can make a payment unlawful. The government proposes banning payments by public sector bodies and regulated critical national infrastructure operators. Take legal advice before any payment decision.

Who must be told about a ransomware attack in the UK?

Depending on sector and facts: the ICO within 72 hours if personal data is at risk under UK GDPR, the FCA or PRA if regulated, Action Fraud or the NCSC, and insurers under policy terms. Proposed reforms would add mandatory ransomware reporting.

What is the UK government’s proposed ransomware payment ban?

Following its 2025 consultation, the government proposes prohibiting ransomware payments by public sector bodies and owners and operators of regulated critical national infrastructure, plus a payment prevention regime requiring other victims to notify authorities first. No bill is in force yet.

Who should decide whether to pay a ransom?

The board or a delegated crisis committee should own the decision, informed by the CISO, general counsel, CFO and external incident responders. Agreeing decision rights, thresholds and legal checks in advance prevents rushed, poorly governed choices during an attack.

About INFORMD. INFORMD provides intelligence briefings, tools and frameworks for senior business leaders across technology, finance, strategy and compliance. Based in Milton Keynes, UK, we help executives stay informed and act with confidence. Explore our full briefing library (/resources/) or access our free assessment tools (/tools-assessments/).

Stay ahead. Subscribe to INFORMD’s weekly executive briefing at informd.co.uk (/resources/).

Similar Posts